Bosch MRC23EVSK vs Porter Cable 895PK

gands1980

I'm a DIY'er with home woodshop. I'm looking to purchase a new router. Currently looking at Bosch MRC23EVSK and Porter Cable 895PK. Any thoughts on which way to go. Paul

dmckinney

Paul,
I am also shopping for a new router and have pretty much narrowed it down to the Bosch MRC23EVSK or Porter-Cable 895PK. The issues I am most conserned with are the soft-start, variable speed, plunge base, and 1/2" collects. Both routers meet those specifications.
The down side is cost. At Rockler.com both routers are $289 to $299. If anyone knows of some better sales it would be appreciated. Also in reviews some people are saying the Porter-Cable has a heating up problem.

On the plus side, the Bosch advertises 1/4" and 1/2" self-releasing collets and the Porter-Cable 895PK includes a Micro- height adjustment knob.

I am leaning towards the Porter-Cable but I am still open and hoping for some more posts on this subject.

Happy Routing,
Danny

Mike

I missed this thread when it started. There really is no comparison between the PC895 and the Bosch MRC23EVSK other than the fact that they are both combo kits. I spent a couple months getting PC to recall the defective bases they issued. Both the plunge and fixed bases were redesigned. In fairness PC did exchange the defective bases for anyone who knew to ask for them. The Bosch "23" has more power, a full 3" plunge depth, LED work lights and a trigger switch so you can start/stop the router with both hands in place. The new power bus means no cord loop between the motor and base to get in the way. The "23" will run you over $300 when you add the optional centering cone, quick release guide bushing adapter and vacuum attachments. These items should be included in the kit! The "23" uses the same bushing adapter, wrenches and collets as the 1617 routers. I am very pleased with mine.

__________________
Mike
"Living in the D" (this means Detroit!)
"It's fine to disagree with other members as long as you respect their opinions"

Joesf

Mike,

The reason I was looking at the PC was that PC seems to be the standard for accessories. Reading the reviews on amazon I was shocked to see over 25 percent of the reviewers gave it one star as recently as may 2011. Thanks for making them do something about some of the problems.

Joe

Mike

Joe, the reason most accessories are for PC is they have been around a long time. Any brand name router will do the job. The Craftsman 2 hp combo for $99 is the least expensive option and is popular because of it's low cost. The Bosch 1617 is the router that started the combo kits. It is an industrial grade router with better construction than many others. You can find the 1617EVSPK at Lowes for $179. Many members like DeWalt and right now Rockler has posted an after Xmas price of $159 for a 2 hp plunge only. I feel a combo kit is a good choice for starting out since it gives you a fixed base for table mounting and a plunge base for free hand use. The best idea is for you to get them in your hands and see which feels best to you.

__________________
Mike
"Living in the D" (this means Detroit!)
"It's fine to disagree with other members as long as you respect their opinions"

Joesf

Thanks Mike,

Can the dewalt be used in a table as well?

Joe

Mike

Most plunge routers can be used in a table; most need to have the springs removed for best results

__________________
Mike
"Living in the D" (this means Detroit!)
"It's fine to disagree with other members as long as you respect their opinions"

bobj3

hi

__________________
"It's fine to disagree with other members as long as you respect their opinions"

MANY,MANY help files on John's web site
http://legacy.woodshopdemos.com/menu2.htm

Sommerfeld Tools ,Videos
http://www.youtube.com/channel/UCT-n...RWaEpMA/videos

Joesf

Thanks guys, I ordered the 1617evspk from amazon $159. Since all I have now is a craftsman fixed base 1 1/2 horse power this should be a big move up. I am also looking at a rousseau supersize table now that they have a new fence system. How do you think the Bosch will work in that table?