Hi Dave, just saw this string again and want to add something about insulating. Start by putting in radiant barrier, an aluminized bubble wrap you staple to the underside of the roof. It is designed to reflect radiant heat back toward its source. It only has an R4 insulation value, but when I added it to the underside of the roof in the garage (I live in the desert and it was summer), we measured the roof temperature on the barrier side and again on the raw ply side. There was nearly 40 degrees difference! So with the R38 insulation between rafters, the garage stays moderate in both summer and winter. The barrier reflects heat from the inside back toward the inside, so until I open the garage door, it stays reasonable on both hot and cold days.
I choose to spend the extra $200 on the barrier because I've used it in my shop shed and again in my office shed, both against the roof and in the walls. It was so effective out there, there was no question about using it in the garage.
My garage has a roll up type door with four sections. I insulated it by laying in the radiant barrier against the steel door, then added 1.5 inch foam blocks, then added a second layer of barrier over that. On the hottest and coldest days (4 degrees in winter, 114 in summer), you can touch the insulation and it is never really hot or cold.
The ceiling was dry walled after insulating, but the walls had fire retardent drywall installed already, so there was no reasonable way to lay in the barrier in the walls (VERY expensive to replace it), so the blown in insulation is not nearly as effective as it is, for example, in my shop. The contractor Drilled and screened vent holes in the insulation stops, and added some plastic venting that conducts air past the insulation. He also installed a thermostat controlled exhaust fan, plus an attic access right next to the fan (They don't last long out here in the heat).
If money were no object, I would have had the garage drywall removed, added a 2x2 to each stud, installed the radiant barrier, then put R38 insulation on top of that, then new drywall. The Blown in insulation is only about R13, and is cold to the touch in winter.
Thought I'd share what has been a very successful approach to insulation--the radiant barrier.
--DRT