Router Forums banner

Incra CleanSweep Magnalock rings

15K views 23 replies 13 participants last post by  bryansong  
#1 ·
I purchased a set of the Incra CleanSweep rings for my Incra/JessEm Mast-R-Lift II router lift. These have special cutouts to improve dust collection. I am very happy with the results. The first picture shows the 1" clean sweep ring in place.

I did a simple test - routing a 3/8" x 1/2" rabbet in some pine. I have the lift on a shop built table with under table DC. With the stock rings in place DC is fairly good though when pushing the work piece into the bit, a plume of dust and chips shoots forward. Most of this plume escapes dust collection and a lot of it goes completely off the table. With the clean sweep rings, the plume is mostly pulled into the openings. In the second picture, I gathered all the chips/dust from the test with the stock ring. The third picture is from the test with the clean sweep ring. All that was left were some larger chips. Amazingly good.

Note that I don't have a dust port in the fence. With the clean sweep rings, I really don't need one and am very happy not to have to monkey with a fence mounted hose.

Overall, I am very happy with these rings.

And a great customer support story here too. Several of the rings didn't seat properly in the lift plate but Incra very quickly responded that they are sending replacements. I continue to be a big Incra fan.
 

Attachments

#4 ·
Phil
Do you recall if you can buy the insert rings indivully. I have two sets of the standard ones, but only use about three of them.

I experimented by drilling holes in one of the standard ones nne, and like you said, it made a world of difference as did drilling holes in my zero clearance TS insert for that matter.

Jerry
 
#5 ·
Phil
Do you recall if you can buy the insert rings indivully. I have two sets of the standard ones, but only use about three of them.

I experimented by drilling holes in one of the standard ones nne, and like you said, it made a world of difference as did drilling holes in my zero clearance TS insert for that matter.

Jerry
Yes, www incrementaltools.com has them.

Somebody else might be cheaper...
 
#11 ·
Phil I bought those last year . Maybe I better test fit them and see if there ok now that mentioned some of yours didn't fit properly :(
Incredible that a company could screw that up this day and age with the technology available
 
#13 ·
On the price, I got a discount offer from them (10%) so I went with incrementaltools.com. They really are the online arm of incra as the products I have bought from them all shipped from the Incra Shipping Department. Part of the good service I got was that they had my name and address already. I don't think they would discriminate against other sellers but I bet it wouldn't go as fast. We are only talking a few bucks difference. If it was 20 or more, I'd be shopping around.

I couldn't find them on amazon but carbide processors has them even cheaper. I know people like their service.
 
#18 ·
I have a Rockler table and plate so to make the Incra work I will have to somehow route out a new hole to accept the Incra plate. They make a Incra Router table adapter that bolts on underneath the table to make the ledge for the plate to drop on to so hopefully I'll be able to take advantage of their Clean Sweep rings/plate.
 
#21 ·
I finally took a look at the WMA. Looks like a really nice piece of engineering.

Comparing it to the LS positioner, I see a number of differences. Probably the biggest is it doesn't have the repeatability of the Incra. The WMA looks to be more substantial than the LS positioner - solid aluminum block and brass guides. It looks almost indestructible. The Incra is extruded aluminum. The WMA has 2 threaded lock downs - it's not going to move, period. The Incra is held down by 4 (or 6) bolts but has a long arm - pretty solid but not like the WMA. The WMA microadjust is a knob where 1 full rotation is 1/32" (but no scale to know how far you've gone). In Incra's favor though, you get 1/32 inch "coarse lock" adjust, .001" incremental microadjust via a click wheel (actually, 1/1024"), a movable magnetic scale and room for 4 additional scales which can include templates. The repeatability means you can use the LS to make all sorts of joints with a high degree of precision. I think the Incra LS is easier to install (4 holes vs 2 T Tracks) and the LS system looks a bit cheaper than the superfence + micro adjust.

If I hadn't used the LS positioner, the solid engineering of the WMA+superfence would make me take a much closer look. In the end though, I probably would still pick the LS since you get a lot more than just microadjust.