And for someone like me ,that would take days to get right . Although a cnc is not a replacement for all your tools, it certainly has its place .
Can’t wait to get one
Can’t wait to get one
That's a beautiful gear. Is it part of a large mechanism?Oliver, It took over two weeks to make my gear (22-1/2" Diameter). Makes me jealous. A perfect application for cnc routing. Nice job!
You cannot really make EXACTLY that out of WOOD with a CNC router unless you use plywood or or some composite material or plastic or metal.Oliver, It took over two weeks to make my gear (22-1/2" Diameter). Makes me jealous. A perfect application for cnc routing. Nice job!
Define Exactly. Define Wood.You cannot really make EXACTLY that out of WOOD with a CNC router unless you use plywood or or some composite material or plastic or metal.
For precision gears CNC waterjet or CNC laser cutter or CNC Plasma (for metals only) would be better than a CNC router.
My thoughts exactly????????That's a beautiful gear. Is it part of a large mechanism?
Gary's gear wheel done manually had all the wood grain in the correct directions,Define Exactly. Define Wood.
Herb
Gary , I wish you had some pictures of this gear from start to finish . I keep finding myself gravitating to it . The more you look at it, the more you realize just how labour intense and intricate this would be to build .Oliver, It took over two weeks to make my gear (22-1/2" Diameter). Makes me jealous. A perfect application for cnc routing. Nice job!
If he made the blank in segments just like he did, and then cut the teeth , spokes, and hub with the CNC it would be faster and more accurate than cutting the teeth and finishing the spokes and hub than doing it by hand is what he was pointing out. Also less hand work to correct any errors from doing it all by hand.Gary's gear wheel done manually had all the wood grain in the correct directions,
If one just cut it from a sheet of wood by CNC router, some spokes for e.g. will be weaker because of wrong wood grain orientation.
So Plywood or other materials will be needed and so the gear will NOT be exactly the same.
Plus doing it by hand would still produce all the same errors if done with a single piece of wood. It would just talks a lot longer and be less perfect in symmetry.If he made the blank in segments just like he did, and then cut the teeth , spokes, and hub with the CNC it would be faster and more accurate than cutting the teeth and finishing the spokes and hub than doing it by hand is what he was pointing out. Also less hand work to correct any errors from doing it all by hand.
Herb
Not a working gear? Who the heck cares ,it’s a work of art !Although it can't be used as a working gear...It now sits on my fireplace as a display.
.
Yes I don’t mean to side track the thread . A cnc is the ultimate for making gears imo .Back to the original post, I think that Oliver has made a good point comparing the amount of time required and the accuracy of doing this by hand and again with the CNC. Even drawing the gear with a CAD program is astoundingly faster than by hand, he can draw and cut the gear faster than sharpening his pencil.
I agree with Rick on Gary's gear, that is a work of art.
Herb
Not for a clock, Gary. It's for another one of Professor Henry's Mechanical Marvels. Still trying to figure out some of the mechanical workings, but fortunately I'm making headway. Stay tuned. (There's a clue in this paragraph.)Oliver, I am still Jealous, using the CNC method would make the spoke sections perfect. It would make the rim sections perfect. It could have made the teeth morticed and tenoned perfect. It could have made a working gear! I'm Jealous! Is your gear for a clock mechanism?