Buying a new router; yes. 
That is an excellent summation on anyone's situation going forward, Phil - an a true acknowledgment of the need for a proper router plate/lift combination for all matters considered. I've been down this road and don't want to go back!Many routers have 1/2" collets as well as 1/4". Don't know if your CMan router does or not. That's the first thing to consider. As Dan pointed out, though, that may be a quixotic quest.
1/2" shank won't really buy you much more height (depth?). As others have pointed out, something doesn't seem quite right. You should have a fair amount of depth for your router. Are you sure you have it mounted correctly?
Finally, I know people are in love with the musclechuck but I think extensions, in general, are a bad idea. I think the MC is safe but would be very leery of anything else. Especially on a 1/4" shank. A broken bit being flung at 24k RPM isn't fun to dodge - don't ask me how I know this. If nothing else you're gonna get more runout so things like box joints and dovetails will be a problem. Best to just bite the bullet and get a newer router with 1/2" and 1/4" collets. Having both is a very useful thing, btw.